Sign In

Jaak Poldma

Lawyer at Orrick, Herrington & Sutcliffe LLP

Jaak Poldma is a dual-qualified attorney licensed in New York and England & Wales, specializing in representing large companies in litigation and international arbitration in the technology, energy, and infrastructure sectors. With a background as a former professional tennis player, he brings a competitive and passionate advocacy style to his legal practice. Jaak has extensive experience in various aspects of dispute resolution, including case management, discovery, oral advocacy, trial proceedings, and enforcement of arbitral awards.

Highlights

Feb 3 · linkedin

“If the decentralised governance of bitcoin really is a myth, then in my judgment there is much to be said for the submission that bitcoin developers, while acting as developers, owe fiduciary duties to the true owners of that property.” The long-awaited Tulip Trading decision is out—the English Court of Appeal has ruled in favour of Tulip Trading.

All #crypto projects should be paying close attention to this case. The English courts have taken the first step towards defining the legal relationship between token holders and the blockchain developers. Let's see how the scope of the fiduciary duty will be drawn...

As background, the Court of Appeal answered the question whether the developers who look after bitcoin may arguably owe fiduciary duties or duties in tort to an owner of that cryptocurrency.

Although the High Court previously ruled that no serious issue was to be tried, the COA disagreed: “The conclusion is not that there is a fiduciary duty in law in the circumstances alleged by Tulip, only that the case advanced raises a serious issue to be tried. The time to decide on the duty in this case is once the facts are established.”

Para 86 gives a nice summary of the reasoning: I recognise that for Tulip’s case to succeed would involve a significant development of the common law on fiduciary duties.[]  However there is, it seems to me, a realistic argument along the following lines. • The developers of a given network are a sufficiently well defined group to be capable of being subject to fiduciary duties. • Viewed objectively the developers have undertaken a role which involves making discretionary decisions and exercising power for and on behalf of other people, in relation to property owned by those other people.  • That property has been entrusted into the care of the developers. The developers therefore are fiduciaries.  • The essence of that duty is single minded loyalty to the users of bitcoin software.  • The content of the duties includes  a) a duty not to act in their own self interest and  b) also involves a duty to act in positive ways in certain circumstances.  c) It may also, realistically, include a duty to act to introduce code so that an owner’s bitcoin can be transferred to safety in the circumstances alleged by Tulip.

#law #bitcoin #blockchain #cryptocurrency

Jaak Poldma
Add to my network

Location

London, United Kingdom